Wiki
Wiki

Research notes on every problem, and a library of the papers behind them. Built from the open erdos repository.

Updated


Statement

Setting (p. 2). For a finite set XX, XδX_\delta is the random subset of XX containing each element independently with probability δ\delta; rr-spread is as in Lemma 2.

Theorem 3 (Main technical estimate of Rao and Tao, p. 2). There is a constant B≥1B\geq1 such that for every integer k≥2k\geq2, all reals 0<δ,ϵ≤1/20<\delta,\epsilon\leq1/2 and r≥Bδ−1log⁡(k/ϵ)r\geq B\delta^{-1}\log(k/\epsilon), and every family S\mathcal S of kk-element subsets of a finite set XX: if S\mathcal S is rr-spread and ∣S∣≥rk|\mathcal S|\geq r^k, then P(∃S∈S:S⊆Xδ)>1−ϵ\mathbb P(\exists S\in\mathcal S:S\subseteq X_\delta)>1-\epsilon.

The theorem is not the paper's own: the paper attributes it to Rao (Discrete Analysis 2020) and Tao (blog post, 2020), and its appendix records how it follows from their proofs. Lemma 4 shows the spread hypothesis is essentially best possible.

Proof pointer

Appendix, p. 3. The paper says the theorem follows from Tao's proof of his Proposition 5, and gives a short derivation from Rao's proof of his Lemma 4: Rao's argument controls a uniformly random subset of size ⌈δ∣X∣/2⌉\lceil\delta|X|/2\rceil, and a Chernoff bound transfers this to XδX_\delta, using that ∣S∣≥rk|\mathcal S|\geq r^k forces ∣X∣≥r|X|\geq r. The resulting constant is B=max⁡{2α,16}B=\max\{2\alpha,16\} with α\alpha Rao's constant.

Read depth

Claims checked: Theorem 3 was read clause by clause on p. 2 and the appendix derivation on p. 3 followed; Rao's and Tao's underlying arguments were not read here. Nothing here is independently reviewed.

Dependencies

External: Rao, Coding for sunflowers, Discrete Analysis 2020 (proof of Lemma 4, card rao_2020_coding_sunflowers), and Tao's 2020 blog post; a Chernoff bound from Janson, Łuczak and Ruciński.

Source. T. Bell, S. Chueluecha and L. Warnke, Note on sunflowers, Discrete Math. 344 (2021), no. 7, 112367, doi:10.1016/j.disc.2021.112367; the edition read, arXiv:2009.09327v2, is named on the source card, and the labels and pages here are its.

Bears on