Wiki
Wiki

Research notes on every problem, and a library of the papers behind them. Built from the open erdos repository.

Updated

Cambie–Kalviainen small-step walk

../

evidence/: Records the accepted independent source-proof review, exact native subjects, and remaining limits for the Gaussian walk construction.

theorem_1: Gives an infinite sequence in the integer lattice of dimension three with at most sixteen allowed bounded steps and no three collinear points.


Stijn Cambie and Erik Kalviainen, An infinite small-step Z3\mathbb{Z}^3-walk with no collinear triple, arXiv:2609.01766v1 (2026). The manuscript is dated September 1, 2026; arXiv records submission at 18:37:21 UTC that day. Versioned record, versioned PDF.

Source artifact and reading coverage

The canonical local artifact is cambie_kalviainen_2026_small_step_walk.pdf, the two-page v1 PDF. The file's hash was checked against the live versioned PDF. Printed and PDF page numbers coincide. Both pages were visually inspected from rendered images, including Theorem 1, equations (1)–(5), the full proof, attribution, and references. The HTML version was a reading aid; the PDF controls the formulas and version. The arXiv record (https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.01766, read 2026-10-02) names the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license.

The source's single theorem is retained as [[discrete_geometry/cambie_kalviainen_2026_small_step_walk/theorem_1|Theorem 1]], with a complete local reconstruction of the proof on pp. 1–2. The reconstruction and its exact catalog consequence received refutation-failed in independent review on 2026-09-08; a distinct grader passed the report contract and independence. The [[discrete_geometry/cambie_kalviainen_2026_small_step_walk/evidence/verify/source_proof_review|retained review and grade]] identify the exact native subjects, reviewer and grader, reading scope, and limits. This is accepted compilation proof coverage for the v1 Gaussian argument, not a numerical tier or formal-verification claim.

Result and method

The authors use a Gaussian-integer walk driven by the binary digit sum, then encode its four states with square-corner offsets and an increasing height. For every chord, the 2-adic valuation of its squared planar length equals that of its height difference. A collinear triple would force positive integers AA, BB, and A+BA+B to have the same 2-adic valuation, a contradiction. The resulting integer walk has no collinear triple and at most sixteen distinct increments, all in

{−2,−1,0,1,2}2×{1,2,…,7}.\{-2,-1,0,1,2\}^2\times\{1,2,\ldots,7\}.

This resolves Problem 193 as stated, since the step set may be any finite subset of Z3\mathbb{Z}^3. It does not impose positive unit-basis steps. Gerver–Ramsey and Lidbetter are cited for history; their results are not premises of this elementary proof.

Acceptance and separate proof routes

The paper's disclosure states that both authors checked the unconditional theorem. The work was AI-assisted, but neither AI output nor finite computation is a premise of the printed argument. The earlier Hilbert-curve construction, its reported Lean formalization, and the finite computations are separate artifacts; none was built or given statement-fidelity review for this source account.

The joint proof is claim 239 in the catalog discussion. Thomas Bloom agreed that it should be marked solved on September 3, 2026 and explained the subsequent status update on September 4. This is named editorial acceptance; it is not a report specifying Bloom's full proof-reading scope or journal refereeing. On 2026-09-08 the authors' timeline still called outside review and community acceptance pending in its original-theorem paragraph. That inconsistency is preserved separately from Bloom's dated comments.

Bears on. Problem 193.