Wiki
Wiki

Research notes on every problem, and a library of the papers behind them. Built from the open erdos repository.

Updated


Claim. Wouter van Doorn and Terence Tao, Growth rates of sequences governed by the squarefree properties of its translates, arXiv:2512.01087 (posted 30 November 2025, revised 7 December 2025), answers the question of how fast a sequence A={a1<a2<⋯ }A=\{a_1<a_2<\cdots\} with property PP or QQ must grow, with property QQ as in the problem's corrected Statement: n+an+a squarefree for all a∈Aa\in A with a<na<n. Theorem numbers are those of the arXiv version.

  • Property PP (Theorem 1): every such sequence has natural density zero, so aj/j→∞a_j/j\to\infty; conversely for every f→∞f\to\infty there is such a sequence with aj/j≤f(j)a_j/j\le f(j) for all jj. Property PP therefore forces no growth beyond density zero, against Erdős's expectation.
  • Property QQ (Theorems 2 and 3): every such sequence has upper density at most 6/π26/\pi^2, and a squarefree sequence with property QQ and natural density exactly 6/π26/\pi^2 exists.
  • Which growth gives QQ (Theorems 4 and 6): a sequence avoiding a residue class modulo p2p^2 for every prime pp (admissible) with aj≥exp⁡(Cj/log⁡j)a_j\ge\exp(Cj/\log j) for infinitely many jj, C>4C>4 any constant, has property QQ; in particular 2n±12^n\pm1 and n!±1n!\pm1 have property QQ. Growth alone does not suffice: an admissible squarefree sequence with aj≥exp⁡(cj1/2/log⁡1/2j)a_j\ge\exp(cj^{1/2}/\log^{1/2}j) and without property QQ exists.

The paper also treats Erdős's further properties P‾\overline P and P‾∞\overline P_\infty (upper density strictly below 6/π26/\pi^2, approachable from below) and the maximal admissible subset of {1,…,x}\{1,\ldots,x\}; the library card lists the theorems. Whether 2n±12^n\pm1 or n!±1n!\pm1 has property PP is left open, a side question of the site's commentary and not of the statement.

Acceptance. The site's curator, Thomas Bloom, credits the paper with the result: the problem page is labeled SOLVED (LEAN) and its commentary (last edited 2 December 2025, accessed 2026-10-07) states that most of the questions are resolved by this paper and summarizes the density results above; the thread's posts of October and November 2025 carry the arguments' development before the paper, and the arXiv announcement was posted there on 2 December 2025. Both authors took part in that thread; the curator is independent of them, and their credit is the reviewed evidence listed. Refereed: the paper is published as Growth rates of sequences governed by the squarefree properties of their translates, Acta Arith. 224 (2026), 173–195 (DOI 10.4064/aa251207-28-5, published online 10 July 2026), the paper link. The formal-conjectures catalog tags four statements covering the property-PP and property-QQ theorems research solved and registers the property-PP and property-QQ density files below. Nothing is independently reviewed by this project.

Formalization. On 23 February 2026 the first author posted four Lean files in the repository Woett/Lean-files, one per theorem group, whose proofs were produced by Aristotle, Harmonic's prover, as the post and every file header name it; the headers state the toolchain, Lean v4.24.0 with a pinned Mathlib commit, and the four files total 7,085 lines. The property-PP and property-QQ files end by proving the catalog's statements for Problem 1102, and the catalog pins those two files at the commit of the links dated 23 February 2026; at that commit the P‾\overline P and fast-growth files take the prime-number-theorem asymptotics they need as a hypothesis, the structure SieveAssumptions. On 4 May 2026 the first author replaced all four files with versions for Lean v4.28.0, 7,446 lines in all, which the author describes as fully unconditional: the P‾\overline P file builds SieveAssumptions from Chebyshev bounds, and the fast-growth file no longer uses it. The post's online type-checker links, which run Mathlib v4.28.0, load these later files. The catalog's own statement file for the problem is not a formalization of the paper and is not linked here. Nothing was built or audited here, so formalized is not listed and the site's (LEAN) suffix warrants no kernel credit.

Scope. Full for the corrected Statement's question, which asks how fast sequences with property PP or QQ must increase: the paper gives the sharp density answer for each property and a sufficient growth condition for QQ. The commentary's side questions about property PP for the special sequences remain open and are not part of this claim.

Depends on. No page of this wiki.