Wiki
Wiki

Research notes on every problem, and a library of the papers behind them. Built from the open erdos repository.

Updated


Claim. H. Rohrbach, Ein Beitrag zur additiven Zahlentheorie, Math. Z. 42 (1937), 1--30. A system of kk non-negative integers, the zero counted, is a 22-basis for nn if every integer 0,1,…,n0,1,\ldots,n is a sum of two of its elements; the least such kk is the g(n)g(n) of Problem 791 (p. 4). The paper proves:

  • Satz 3 (p. 5): a minimal 22-basis for n>1n>1 has fewer than 2n2\sqrt n elements, that is g(n)<2ng(n)<2\sqrt n, by the explicit basis (6) of Satz 2;
  • the Folgerung to Satz 6 (pp. 14--15): every 22-basis of kk elements for nn has n≤k2/2n\le k^2/2, so g(n)2≥2ng(n)^2\ge2n whenever g(n)≥5g(n)\ge5;
  • inequality (47) (p. 18): every 22-basis of kk elements for nn has n<0.4992 k2n<0.4992\,k^2 once kk is large enough.

Since g(n)≥2n→∞g(n)\ge\sqrt{2n}\to\infty, (47) applies to a minimal basis for all large nn and gives n<0.4992 g(n)2n<0.4992\,g(n)^2, that is g(n)2>(2.0032…)ng(n)^2>(2.0032\ldots)n for large nn. Together with Satz 3 this is the site's (2+c)n≤g(n)2≤4n(2+c)n\le g(n)^2\le4n, with c=0.0032c=0.0032.

Covers. The bounds g(n)<2ng(n)<2\sqrt n for n>1n>1 and g(n)2>(2.0032…)ng(n)^2>(2.0032\ldots)n for large nn. Not covered: the estimate of g(n)g(n) beyond these constants. The paper's conjecture n2(k)=k2/4+O(k)n_2(k)=k^2/4+O(k) (p. 9) is the problem's "in particular" question and is not a claim; it is refuted on Hämmerer and Hofmeister's claim page and Mrose's.

Depends on.

Acceptance. Refereed: the paper is published in Mathematische Zeitschrift (Crossref: 1937-12), which dates this page. The site's curator, Thomas F. Bloom, attributes these bounds to Rohrbach in the problem's commentary, but the site labels the problem OPEN, so the attribution is not listed as reviewed. The proof of Satz 3 is followed on the result page; the proofs of the lower bounds in §§ 3--5 are not checked in this corpus.