Wiki
Wiki

Research notes on every problem, and a library of the papers behind them. Built from the open erdos repository.

Updated


Source. Ramsey (1930), Part II, printed p. 276 (PDF, physical p. 13).

Use the forms and system PP from the preceding reduction. Let NN be an integer with 1≤N≤n1\leq N\leq n.

The universal sentence has a model on exactly NN elements if and only if PP contains an NN-form ANA_N together with every smaller form involved in ANA_N.

Necessity

Suppose a model has universe U={u1,…,uN}U=\{u_1,\ldots,u_N\}. Evaluate every relation atom on this ordered list. The resulting complete canonical alternative lies in one NN-form ANA_N. Since the universal sentence holds, the NN-row of PP must contain that form.

For every subset of μ<N\mu<N elements, restrict the same truth assignment to the atoms involving only that subset and relabel its elements. This realizes one of the μ\mu-forms involved in ANA_N. Every possible choice and ordering of the subset occurs among the assignments quantified by the sentence, so each such involved form must occur in the μ\mu-row of PP. Thus ANA_N is completely contained through all smaller sizes.

Sufficiency

Conversely, suppose PP contains ANA_N and every form involved in it. Choose one complete alternative q∈ANq\in A_N and label an NN-element universe by y1,…,yNy_1,\ldots,y_N. Define each relation on every tuple of these elements by the truth value assigned to the corresponding atom in qq. Equality consistency of qq makes this a well-defined interpretation. Its nullary literals, if any, give the shared truth values of the propositional constants.

The original complete alternative listed every relation atom formed from the xix_i. Since each of the NN equality classes contains an xix_i, it therefore specifies every relation tuple on this NN-element universe, including tuples with repeated entries.

Consider any assignment of x1,…,xnx_1,\ldots,x_n in this structure. It uses some μ≤N\mu\leq N distinct elements. After the equality reduction, its complete truth alternative is obtained by restricting qq to those elements and then permuting their labels. If μ=N\mu=N, this is a representative of ANA_N itself; if μ<N\mu<N, it belongs to a μ\mu-form involved in ANA_N. In either case the form occurs in PP. Hence FF is true under every assignment, so the constructed structure is a model.

The condition is exact for each prescribed nonempty cardinality N≤nN\leq n. Empty universes are outside the source's convention.