Wiki
Wiki

Research notes on every problem, and a library of the papers behind them. Built from the open erdos repository.

Updated


Statement

Notation: ϱ∗(x)\varrho^*(x) is the largest number of elements of an admissible sequence in an interval of length xx, as defined on the page for Conjecture B.

Result (§ 3, printed p. 1717; unnumbered). The authors exhibit

  • an admissible sequence of 715715 points in an interval of length 53805380, while π(5380)=708\pi(5380)=708;
  • an admissible subsequence of it of 657657 points in an interval of length 49164916, while π(4916)=656\pi(4916)=656, given by its residue-class description in Table 4 (p. 1717).

Hence ϱ∗(5380)≥715>π(5380)\varrho^*(5380)\ge715>\pi(5380) and ϱ∗(4916)≥657>π(4916)\varrho^*(4916)\ge657>\pi(4916). The paper sets these against the earlier examples it recalls on p. 1717: Hensley, Richards and Stenberg's ϱ∗(20000)>π(20000)\varrho^*(20000)>\pi(20000), and Vehka and Richards's admissible sequence of 14121412 points in length 1176311763, where π(11763)=1409\pi(11763)=1409.

The result is unconditional and concerns admissible sequences, not primes. By the prime kk-tuples conjecture (Conjecture A, p. 1713), each such sequence would have infinitely many translates consisting of primes, giving intervals of length 49164916 with more primes than [1,4916][1,4916]; the paper does not prove that any such translate exists.

Source. David A. Clark and Norman C. Jarvis, "Dense admissible sequences," Mathematics of Computation 70(236) (2001), 1713--1718, https://doi.org/10.1090/s0025-5718-01-01348-5; § 3, p. 1717. The edition read is identified on the source card.

Read depth. Claims checked: the statements and Table 4 were read on the page image of p. 1717. The admissibility of the sequences was not recomputed and nothing here is independently reviewed.

Proof pointer

§ 3, p. 1717. The authors pick lengths xx with π(x)−Li⁡(x)\pi(x)-\operatorname{Li}(x) small, try every combination of erased residue classes for the first nn primes, and for each later prime erase the class removing the fewest surviving elements. With n=9n=9 this gave the 715-point sequence in about nine days of computation; a search inside it for a denser shorter stretch gave the 657-point subsequence.

Dependencies

None beyond the computation.

Bears on

  • Problem 855: under the prime kk-tuples conjecture, Table 4 gives π(y+4916)−π(y)≥657>π(4916)\pi(y+4916)-\pi(y)\ge657>\pi(4916) for infinitely many yy, and the 715-point sequence an excess of at least seven at length 53805380. With xx fixed, this contradicts the problem's inequality only if its threshold for "large" is below these lengths; it is a conditional violation at fixed lengths, not an asymptotic counterexample.