Research notes on every problem, and a library of the papers behind them. Built from the open erdos repository.
Updated
Source. T. Tao, discussion comment on the Problem 251 page, 17:17 on 07 Oct 2025 (site clock): "By summation by parts, this is equivalent to the irrationality of ." The comment states the equivalence in one line; the proof below is written out here and checked; it is elementary and complete.
Statement
Let be the primes and the prime gaps. Both series below converge and
so is irrational if and only if is irrational.
Proof
Convergence: by Chebyshev's elementary bound , the terms are , so converges; the identity below then gives the convergence of the gap series, whose terms are positive.
For every ,
the sum being empty for . Multiply by and sum over . All terms are nonnegative, so the order of summation may be exchanged:
since and . Hence , and is rational exactly when the gap series is rational.
Numerically (OEIS A098990), so the gap series equals .
Variants used by the 2026 manuscripts
For an integer base the same computation gives (Ringer's equation (1)); with zero-based indexing , , it reads (Cook's form). Land works with the weighted tails , whose first value is .
Relation to Problem 251
The identity changes nothing about the problem's status; it shows that the question is about the binary expansion of the dyadic series of prime gaps, where each gap on average occupies several binary digits and the contributions overlap, so carries couple distant terms. Every 2026 manuscript on the problem starts from this form.
Bears on. #251 (an exact reformulation, not progress).