Research notes on every problem, and a library of the papers behind them. Built from the open erdos repository.
Updated
Source. Published pp. 3–4, Lemma 3.1 and its proof.
Statement. For every integer , some has this property: any real array , , satisfying is realized as the squared pair distances of vertices in a brick of dimension , with every edge length positive. No prior realizability assumption on the array is necessary.
Proof. Index coordinates by pairs . For positive numbers , let the proposed vertex have coordinate when and zero otherwise. It is a vertex of the brick with coordinate edge lengths . Put . The required squared distances are precisely
Let be this square system's by coefficient matrix. The row indexed by is the incidence vector of
Each row has ones. For pairs sharing one vertex, say and , the common members are the edges from to another vertex, together with , so . For disjoint pairs and , the common members are , so the intersection size is four.
Take , , . The two intersection sizes are congruent modulo , but for . The fully proved modular independence lemma therefore makes the rows independent over . Since is a square integer matrix, its determinant is nonzero and it is invertible over .
For the all-ones array, the solution is . The solution varies continuously with the finite vector . Choose a sufficiently small neighborhood of the all-ones array so every coordinate of stays positive; then set . The displayed equations give every required distance and complete the proof.
Scope. The source selects this combinatorial invertibility argument; it is retained here with its quoted input expanded. No optimal value of or classification of the smaller values of is asserted. The source's warning about concerns this lemma, not the failure of all four-point configurations to be Ramsey.
Bears on. #174.