Wiki
Wiki

Research notes on every problem, and a library of the papers behind them. Built from the open erdos repository.

Updated


Source. Croot, published paper, p. 235, Lemma 2. The factorial estimate compressed in the source is expanded here, including the endpoint needed in Theorem 1.

Write

ω(n)=#{p:p prime, p∣n},B(x)=log⁡xlog⁡log⁡x,T(x)=log⁡xlog⁡log⁡x.\omega(n)=\#\{p:p\text{ prime},\ p\mid n\},\quad B(x)=\sqrt{\frac{\log x}{\log\log x}},\quad T(x)=\sqrt{\log x\log\log x}.

Statement. For each fixed c>0c>0,

#{n≤x:ω(n)≥cB(x)}≤xexp⁡(−(c2+o(1))T(x)).\#\{n\le x:\omega(n)\ge cB(x)\} \le x\exp\left(-\left(\frac c2+o(1)\right)T(x)\right).

In particular this bounds the strict inequality in the printed lemma too.

Complete proof. Set r=⌈cB(x)⌉r=\lceil cB(x)\rceil. For xx sufficiently large, r≥1r\ge1. An integer with ω(n)≥r\omega(n)\ge r contains a set of rr distinct prime divisors. Counting such sets gives

#{n≤x:ω(n)≥r}≤∑n≤x(ω(n)r)=∑p1<⋯<pr≤x⌊xp1⋯pr⌋≤xr!(∑p≤x1p)r.\begin{aligned} \#\{n\le x:\omega(n)\ge r\} &\le\sum_{n\le x}\binom{\omega(n)}r\\ &=\sum_{p_1<\cdots<p_r\le x} \left\lfloor\frac{x}{p_1\cdots p_r}\right\rfloor\\ &\le\frac{x}{r!}\left(\sum_{p\le x}\frac1p\right)^r. \end{aligned}

The elementary reciprocal-prime estimate is A(x)=O(log⁡log⁡x)A(x)=O(\log\log x), and

log⁡(r!)=∑j=1rlog⁡j≥∫1rlog⁡t dt=rlog⁡r−r+1.\log(r!)=\sum_{j=1}^r\log j \ge\int_1^r\log t\,dt=r\log r-r+1.

Consequently the logarithm of the factor multiplying xx is at most

−rlog⁡r+rlog⁡A(x)+r=−(c2+o(1))T(x).-r\log r+r\log A(x)+r =-\left(\frac c2+o(1)\right)T(x).

Indeed, r=(c+o(1))B(x)r=(c+o(1))B(x), log⁡r=12log⁡log⁡x+O(log⁡log⁡log⁡x)\log r=\tfrac12\log\log x+O(\log\log\log x), and log⁡A(x)=O(log⁡log⁡log⁡x)\log A(x)=O(\log\log\log x). Thus rlog⁡r=(c/2+o(1))T(x)r\log r=(c/2+o(1))T(x), while both remaining terms are o(T(x))o(T(x)).

Source clarification. No estimate that is uniform in a growing cc is used. The weak threshold above also covers the discarded ω(n)≥B(x)\omega(n)\ge B(x) class in Theorem 1, even when B(x)B(x) is an integer.

Bears on. Theorem 1 and Problem 202.