Wiki
Wiki

Research notes on every problem, and a library of the papers behind them. Built from the open erdos repository.

Updated


Source. Erdős (1945), Theorem 1 and its proof, printed p. 898 (published scan).

Statement. Let N≥1N\ge1 and let x1,…,xNx_1,\ldots,x_N be real numbers with ∣xi∣≥1|x_i|\ge1. In any open interval of length two, the number of assignments ε∈{−1,1}N\varepsilon\in\{-1,1\}^N satisfying ∑iεixi\sum_i\varepsilon_i x_i in that interval is at most

BN=(N⌊N/2⌋).B_N=\binom N{\lfloor N/2\rfloor}.

The same bound holds for either half-open interval of length two. The bound is attained for every N≥1N\ge1.

Proof. Replace a negative xix_i by −xi-x_i and simultaneously replace its sign coordinate εi\varepsilon_i by −εi-\varepsilon_i. This is a bijection of assignments preserving every sum, so assume all xi≥1x_i\ge1.

For an assignment let A={i:εi=1}A=\{i:\varepsilon_i=1\}. Its sum is

ZA=2∑i∈Axi−∑i=1Nxi.Z_A=2\sum_{i\in A}x_i-\sum_{i=1}^N x_i.

If A⊊DA\subsetneq D, then

ZD−ZA=2∑i∈D∖Axi≥2.Z_D-Z_A=2\sum_{i\in D\setminus A}x_i\ge2.

Any two points of an open or half-open interval of length two have distance strictly less than two. The subsets corresponding to the qualifying assignments therefore form an antichain. By Theorem 4 with r=1r=1, this family has size at most BNB_N. Distinct assignments correspond to distinct subsets, so coincident numerical sums are counted with their proper multiplicity.

For sharpness, take all xi=1x_i=1. A rank-kk subset gives sum 2k−N2k-N with multiplicity (Nk)\binom Nk. The open interval of length two centered at 2⌊N/2⌋−N2\lfloor N/2\rfloor-N contains exactly the central rank, since consecutive rank sums differ by two. Its count is BNB_N. □\square

Scope. The source cites Sperner's theorem; the linked same-paper shadow proof supplies that input here. The source explicitly gives sharpness for even NN; the displayed center also handles odd NN. A closed interval of length two does not satisfy the theorem: for N=1,x1=1N=1,x_1=1, the interval [−1,1][-1,1] contains two assignments, whereas B1=1B_1=1.

Bears on. Problem 498: proves the problem's bound BNB_N when every input is real, since an open unit disk meets the real line in an open interval of length at most two.