Wiki
Wiki

Research notes on every problem, and a library of the papers behind them. Built from the open erdos repository.

Updated


Source. Alain Plagne, Recent progress on finite Bh[g]B_h[g] sets, author's manuscript (no venue or year printed), Section 4 (pp. 13-15), the problems on p. 14, as identified on the source card. The file prints no page numbers; pages are counted from its first page.

Statement

Setting. F3,1(N)F_{3,1}(N) is the largest size of a subset of {1,…,N}\{1,\ldots,N\} in which every integer has at most one representation a1+a2+a3a_1+a_2+a_3 with a1≤a2≤a3a_1\le a_2\le a_3 (p. 1, formula (1)), and c3,1c_{3,1} is the limit of F3,1(N)/N1/3F_{3,1}(N)/N^{1/3} when it exists (Problem 6).

Problem 9 (p. 14, quoted). "Estimate conjecturally c3,1c_{3,1} (is c3,1=1c_{3,1}=1 reasonable?) or at least find an efficient algorithm to compute the largest B3[1]B_3[1] set in {1,…,N}\{1,\ldots,N\}."

The paper introduces it, after Problem 8, as "the easier problem" (p. 14). Its table (p. 13) gives, for (h,g)=(3,1)(h,g)=(3,1), the lower bound 11 from Bose and Chowla and the upper bound 1.51831.5183 from Green, so 1≲F3,1(N)N−1/3≲(7/2)1/3=1.5182…1\lesssim F_{3,1}(N)N^{-1/3}\lesssim(7/2)^{1/3}=1.5182\ldots (p. 10; the table rounds it to 1.5183).

Read depth. Claims checked: the problem and the bounds were read on pp. 10, 13 and 14. An open problem; there is no proof to check.

Proof pointer

None: an open problem.

Dependencies

Problem 6 for the definition of c3,1c_{3,1}.

Bears on

  • Problem 241: the problem's f(N)f(N) is the paper's F3,1(N)F_{3,1}(N), sums of three counted with a≤b≤ca\le b\le c, and it asks whether f(N)∼N1/3f(N)\sim N^{1/3}, that is, whether c3,1c_{3,1} exists and equals 11. Problem 9 asks whether c3,1=1c_{3,1}=1 is reasonable as a conjecture; the paper proves nothing on it.